| Innovative Stamp Clubs |
The following article appeared in APF News in three parts over the period June 2000 to February 2001. It is published here for the benefit and interest of the wider philatelic community. The APF hopes that you will find some of the experiences of Australia's leading philatelic societies useful. Visitors to www.apf.org.au are welcome to contribute their thoughts and experiences to the APF Webmaster who is keen to see a further article written at some time in the future.
* * *
1. Annual General Meetings:
One of the most common commentaries read on club AGMs is that they took only a short space of time to conduct, resulted in the same committee being return to office without the need for elections, with no others interested in taking on committee roles.
But some of our more innovative clubs are making their AGM a real occasion in the form of an Annual Dinner & Presentation night at a restaurant. AGMs are normally the customary time to induct Life Members but some clubs are also taking this opportunity to present their various competition trophies. This makes good practical sense since it gives clubs time to arrange certificates, engraving, and any other necessary arrangements. Combine these with a few other innovative elements like "roast" speeches, a door prize (say a bottle of wine), a "last man standing wins" quiz (described below), the surprise presence of a few past and long lost members, and who knows, your members may even grow to look forward to their AGM. The club might even think about subsidising the cost as an added incentive.
2. Quiz Competitions:The most common format for a philatelic quiz is one in which all members complete a set of questions, usually without being able to consult albums or reference books, with the person with the highest number of correct answers being declared the winner. The main criticism of this format is that the quiz is inevitably won by the same one or two individuals. Another dilemma is how to set the questions without advantaging or disadvantaging anyone. This latter problem can be easily addressed by having someone outside the club set the questions. Two clubs can collaborate to set questions for each other. In Victoria, the Victorian Philatelic Council offers a quiz question setting service.
There are however numerous other formats and variations that can be employed. One is to apply handicaps. An example is that winners are automatically handicapped for the following year. One society has adopted a "two division" format with a relegation / promotion system whereby previous winners compete in their own division with a set of more challenging questions. The lowest scorer in this division is relegated to the other division. At the same time, the winner of the second division earns promotion to the top division for the following year. Who said that there can only be one winner at a time?
A fun way of conducting a quiz is to use a "true or false" knock-out format. The competition begins by the caller reading our the first question. All participants raise either their left or right hand to designate true or false. Wrong answers are immediately eliminated whilst those responding correctly survive to answer the next question. The last man standing wins (or there could be a tie if all remaining competitors are eliminated on the same question). A good way of sharing the glory around is to conduct several rounds with the winner of round one becoming the question reader of round two, and so on.
3. The Scavenger Hunt:Scavenger Hunts or Treasure Hunts as they are sometimes called, are a fun and often surprisingly entertaining stamp club activity. Whilst the rules can vary from format to format, the one characteristic which is common is that the aim is for you to find all the specified items.
A list is provided a certain period in advance of the staging of the competition and members are given that period of time to do their hunting. They then bring their items to a meeting where judging / scoring takes place. Two or three months lead time is usual, sometimes longer.
One version allocates a set number of points to each item on the list the harder the item to find, the more points it is worth. A total score of 100 with items varying from 2 to 20 points is typical. Some clubs award bonus points if only one person finds the item.
In another version, the challenge is not simply to find all the items on the list, but to find examples which will be unique relative to every one elses. A scoring scenario might be as follows. Up to twenty points can be gained per item. If you have an item which satisfies the description and your item is different to everyone elses, you score the maximum of 20 points. If two people have the same item, they score 12 points each, 3 the same scores 7 points, 4 the same scores 3 points each, and 5 or more scores just 1 point. The three main features which make this particular form quite fun are:
There are also some tricks to be wary of, so here are a few tips if participating in this type of scavenger hunt:
There are also versions of this type of activity which require participants to write up their items into a mini-exhibit which is then judged.
No matter what form of scavenger hunt of treasure hunt you may be familiar with, the fun is in the hunting, the participation, and the debates which are held at judging time. The editor hasnt heard of a scavenger hunt night being a dull night yet!
4
. Syllabus Ideas Dealer Visits and Dealers "Closed Shop" Nights:For all sorts of reasons, stamp collectors may rarely get the opportunity to visit a dealers shop. It may be that there simply isnt a stamp shop close by, a common problem of many country collectors; or the dealers who are based in the vicinity are either home-based mail order businesses only or do not open on weekends.
There are two ways around this problem, both of which have been used by our more innovative philatelic societies.
The first is to invite a dealer to your meeting as the principal attraction for the evening. If the dealer can be provided with a list of the "wants" and collecting interests of your societys members, then he or she can ensure they bring what you want to see. This neednt be restricted to stamps, as your members may wish to purchase accessories such as catalogues, display sheets, albums, etc. Many dealers who travel regularly to weekend fairs are well equipped to take their stock "on the road" and are only to willing to visit if the opportunity appears it will be worth their while. To this end, why not join up with a neighbouring society and arrange a dealers visit. The Bundaberg Philatelic Society in Queensland is one example of a society offering this type of service to its members.
The second way is for you to visit them. Rather than have a meeting in you usual venue, some dealers may be willing to hold a special "outside of hours" session by arrangement. The same principles as described above apply; if every one benefits, there is no reason why this couldnt feature on your societys next syllabus.
5. Newsletters:It is well accepted that the best way to get your message across is to do it frequently and using different media. Simple once-off announcements of news items are often missed, misinterpreted, forgotten, or just not taken seriously.
Club newsletters are an effective way of reinforcing information, providing your members with that extra little something, and providing some good old fashioned entertainment as well.
The editor is fortunate to have seen many different types of newsletters ranging from one page, dot-point handouts, to elaborate and colourful multi-paged newsletters.
Ongoing publicity for the clubs own syllabus is a great advantage of publishing a newsletter. This ensures members dont forget key dates like annual competitions, annual general meetings, fairs and special events, and any once-off departures from usual meeting arrangements. Publicity for upcoming fairs, State Congresses, special events and exhibitions is also an obvious feature of any good newsletter.
The personal experiences of your fellow club members often bring useful tips and information from which everyone can benefit. It might be as simple as learning that a post office is closing (get in for a final day cancellation) to an error on a new stamp which could be worth a small fortune.
I wonder how many society newsletters print birthday greetings to their members? You can be assured of birthday greetings if you belong to the Gladstone and District Philatelic Society or the Bundaberg Philatelic Society in Queensland. The "Gladstone Bag" published by the Gladstone and District Philatelic Society is also renowned for its jokes and humorous stories, making it a great read even when philatelic news is scarce!
A formal welcome to new members including the publishing of their collecting interests is also a great advantage of having a newsletter. This way, new members can network from the time they join, even if they cant be regular attendees at meetings.
The style and scope of newsletters is only limited by the imagination of its editor and the ideas that its members contribute.
The value of newsletters in attracting and retaining members should not be underestimated. Gauging by the newsletters which are received by the APF, it is not unusual for societies which produce and mail out newsletters to all members to have several thousand members (including many overseas), even when meeting numbers are only a tiny fraction of this.
A final point in favour of newsletters is that they record your societys history often in ways and in a level of detail not normally recorded in the formal minutes of meetings. Your society may never have produced a history book, however such an exercise, should it ever be undertaken, would be that much easier, more thorough and more fun, if a newsletter existed to record it all.
If your club produces a newsletter, the APF PRO would appreciate receiving a copy why not let APF News promote your news and ideas too (please send to P.O Box 4087, Patterson, Victoria, 3204).
6. Members Display Nights and Favourite Philatelic Item Nights:Are there members in your society who seem to remain a constant mystery in terms of their collecting interests? If you answer "yes", you would not be alone. Knowing what your fellow collectors are interested in is important for many reasons. Seeing your auction lots and exchange sheets coming back untouched can become depressing and frustrating, yet there are some simple ways to encourage openness and therefore open up trading and exchange opportunities. A Members Display Night or Favourite Philatelic Item Night could be just the ice-breaker your society needs. And once the ice has been broken, you might be pleasantly surprised at how many tips and bargains your fellow society members might bestow upon each other.
A variation on the Favourite Philatelic Item night is the Unusual Philatelic Item night. It is almost a cross between a Members Display and a Philatelic Quiz in that members bring in an item which is for some reason unique or unusual. The fun part of the idea however is that the item is passed around to see if other members can identify why the item is unique or unusual. Added spice can be provided by offering small rewards to the first person to correctly identify why. Why not try one of these ideas on your societys next syllabus?
7. Hire a Bus and Visit a Fair:If you live in the "big smoke", chances are stamp fairs happen regularly near you and you rarely need to travel far to visit one. But for many stamp collectors, this is far from the case. And even for those of us who are fortunate to be well serviced by stamp fairs, there is always the temptation to make a longer trip one weekend to visit a different fair which is likely to have table holders who you dont normally encounter locally.
A great social activity is to hire a bus, get the club together, and make a day (or weekend) of it. Think of the trip as golf weekend except the clubs are replaced by stamp albums!
Your State Philatelic Council can advise you on when regular fairs are scheduled in your State. You can also get all the latest fair information from the APF website.
8. One Sheet Original Display:It is sometimes argued that one of the greatest draw backs of most traditional exhibiting competitions at club level is that they tend to be dominated by the same entrants who are capable and experienced of mounting excellent displays and seem to have endless quality material at their disposal. Encouraging first time entries is rarely easy and often the club syllabus seems unable to cater for those wanting to display or participate in competition, but in something of a less serious way.
The One Sheet Original Display concept is designed to accommodate the gap. Restricted to just one display page, the competition is based on the "best" idea utilising something philatelic. There arent too many rules and it can be judged by a secret ballot (popular vote) of the meeting. As long as the page contains something philatelic, it is a valid entry.
The idea is to present an original concept or idea using a stamp or stamps or some other philatelic item. It can be poem, a play on words, a product advertisement, a send up of a television program or movie title; the ideas are only limited by your imagination.
Because the winner is based on the creativity of his or her idea, exhibiting experience, the value of philatelic items used, and all the usual rules have no relevance. Put another way, there is NO excuse for any one not to participate. Other pluses of this activity are:
Who knows; perhaps this type of syllabus activity might just prove to some of your club members that they do have the skills to prepare something for exhibiting!
9. Philatelic Crosswords:Crosswords offer an interesting variation to the traditional question and answer style quiz. Because club members need do no preparation, it is easy to get everyone involved they just face up to the task on the night! Like with quizzes, two clubs can always prepare crosswords for each other to try to ensure some objectivity to the clues in the puzzle. You can even have two divisions if the level of philatelic knowledge varies greatly in your club.
10. Letter Hunts:What is a Letter Hunt? The objective of a Letter Hunt is to find as many stamps, covers or philatelic items as you can which feature something beginning with a designated letter of the alphabet. This is a great activity for junior groups, but also offers some variety for a clubs adult syllabus. Like the scavenger hunt, the fun can be in arguing the point when the result is close.
A variation to the idea is to put some of the winning entries on display at the annual club fair. A good title sheet for such as display might read "How many items can you find in your collection featuring something beginning with (say) "B"? Preparing the entry for display need not be a huge task, merely mount the items with a simple tag under each indicating what the item is. You can even use hagner sheets.
11. Creative Annual Fairs:Annual (or more frequent) fairs are a highlight on the calendar of many of our more progressive stamp clubs. Fairs provide important exposure for the club as well as an effective source of new membership. Indeed for the clubs themselves, the number of new members signed is often regarded as a more meaningful measure of performance of a fair than of the total number of visitors through the door.
A first must is effective promotion not just within the club, but in the community generally. Local papers, local radio, shopping centre windows, church gatherings, pamphlet drops in letter boxes, ads in dealers catalogues, your State Council periodic newsletter, APF News, and the APF website are all obvious ways of getting the message out. A professionally looking flyer conveys a more positive message than a simple one, and many of our more innovative clubs are using the ever increasing array of modern software and printing techniques to give their flyers more appeal.
A visitors book is a great idea for monitoring how effective your promotion has been. Logging the names and addresses of visitors (even if the latter is only a suburb name), plus whether they belong to a stamp club or not, and how they came to know about your fair, can be a real eye opener. Those who answer "no" to being a member of a club are an obvious source of new members.
But what will attract people to your fair? At least one society that has come to the attention of APF News has a stated policy of ensuring their fair has at least one new dealer every time and where possible, that dealer should be a person who is not normally seen at other fairs in the region. This initiative aims to ensure that there is always an element of "fresh appeal" for visitors.
Organised club participation is another effective way of boosting numbers at your fair. This can be done in many ways: by staging an interclub competition, by inviting club members from neighbouring clubs to take up tables or provide exhibits, or to man information tables. Interclub competitions can take many forms. One-frame competitions are typical, but many other forms are possible. You can add interest by conducting a quiz or "find it" competition which requires visitors to complete a quiz or find the frame number in which certain items can be found. Find-it competitions are one way of encouraging people to look more closely at exhibits on show at fairs not to mention the fact that they can learn a thing or two from participating in the exercise!
The incentive of a good door prize or two should always be considered. In Melbournes eastern suburbs, a number of fair organisers offer a full suitcase of goodies as the door prize! As filling the suitcase can be a year-long exercise, this in itself can be a great way of building up interest in the fair.
An auction, either catalogued or uncatalogued is always an attraction, especially if you can guarantee a few hundred lots or more, and you can be assured of offering a bargain or two. There are various types of auction that can be run. Dutch Auctions are particularly suited to fairs and run much the way that internet bidding now works; that is, bidders record their bids in a public area and are thus able to monitor bidding until the auction closes. The highest bid when bidding closes becomes the purchaser. A useful feature of this style of activity is that it does tend to keep people there until bids close!
12. When all else is failing - survey:If trying to think what your philatelic society syllabus should offer seems just too hard, there is always one obvious way to find out ask your members! The Tamworth Philatelic Society did this in 1998 and published the results in their monthly newsletter. Their survey helped pinpoint which syllabus activities attracted the most interest and which the least. It also gave the members the opportunity to provide comments and new ideas. It should come as no surprise that the societys newsletter was ranked one of the most strongly supported services / activities provided by the society.